Reviewed : 11/30/2025
Comment : WARNING: Deceptive Business Practices & Hostage Tactics
Read this article and check out the Reddit and Facebook posts before taking your car in. "They Damaged My Car, Then Tried to Blame Me"
I will publish a comprehensive, detailed breakdown, including dates, emails, legal references, and matching 1-star BBB complaints on Reddit and Facebook, to expose the full extent of this shop’s deceptive practices. If you're considering West Hills Collision, read that first. You deserve the truth.
If you are considering West Hills Collision, please review their BBB profile and other 1-star reviews first. You will see a disturbing situation that has happened to me and many others: You bring your car in for one repair, and they damage another part of your car. Then, they hold your car for months, charging you thousands of dollars in storage fees and insurance premiums. They held my car for over 2 months!
1) Unprofessional, Irresponsible, and Fraudulent: This shop seems to operate more like a middleman than a repair facility. They subcontract important work to a third party. While repairing the rear panel, they damaged the rear window defroster. Instead of taking responsibility, they blamed it on "the part that may have worn out, and it no longer works". My car arrived with no problems, and they had the nerve to say that. It wasn't until I mentioned suing them that they began processing my insurance.
Poor Quality & Salvage Parts: Despite my car having original OEM parts, they replaced the broken glass with recycled/salvage glass from a junked vehicle.
2) "Delay Tactics" (Steve): Steve is the initial exchange and pick-up.
When I brought my car in for a rear panel repair, during the repair, you would not receive any information about the car unless you made a call.
Even if they damaged another part of my car, they would quietly inform my insurance that the part was damaged. When the shop damaged my defroster, Steve denied responsibility, claiming it was my car's fault, and the issue was delayed for weeks. He refused to take action until I threatened to contact the DOJ. It seemed like he was there to stall for time, allowing storage fees to accrue.
After dragging out repairs for weeks, they suddenly stopped working on the car altogether and then started threatening $250/day in storage fees, even though I was only waiting for them to fix what they had broken.
3. “Legal Manipulation” (Broc): Broc, the manager, ran the scheme. He initially tried to push the responsibility onto me. When I protested, his attitude changed. He suddenly launched into a complex legal argument (Clearly AI supported), citing specific Oregon Statutes (ORS) to force my insurance company to cover the damage caused by his store, as well as substantial storage fees. He used my situation to inflate the claim amount by thousands of dollars (the storage fees alone caused my bill to skyrocket to over $3,000).
The shop damaged the part (rear defogger) on 22nd October, and when the insurance did not cover the damage caused by the shop, he charged me for the storage fee on 22nd October.
Steve initially said it was my car's fault. After I told him I would take it to court, he informed Broc (the manager) and reiterated that it was the fault of the rear panel repair.
On the day I was finally supposed to pick up my car (11/17), Steve emailed me at 1:08 PM stating the car would be ready at 3:00 PM. Just 32 minutes later (at 1:40 PM), he emailed again, claiming a sudden "front suspension" issue was preventing completion, and moved the car to yet another shop.
The Outcome: They held my car for over two months. I had to file a formal complaint with the Oregon Division of Financial Regulation (DFR) just to resolve the mess they created. Check their BBB profile. I am not the only one this has happened to.
Do not trust them with your vehicle. They will break it, blame you, and then hold it hostage to squeeze money out of your insurance policy.