AAA Approved Auto Repair Shop Reviews PHINNEY`S AUTOMOTIVE CENTER 900 JAMES STREET CLAYTON, NY 13624 Tel: (315) 686-5271 Hours: M-F: 08:00 AM - 06:00 PM Sat: 08:00 AM - 03:00 PM Sun: Closed Reviews Sort Reviews by: Date » or Rating » Page 1 of 35 |<< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 → >| 1 Reviews Gregory topping CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/17/2025 Comment : Great job! Worked on two different cars for me in a short period of time, very reasonably priced and very pleasant service people at the front desk. I strongly recommend them. 1 Reviews Linda bouvier CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/16/2025 Comment : Efficient and cordial staff. Car service top-notch. 1 Reviews Pyro fyter CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/15/2025 Comment : Always have had great service at Phinney’s. They go above and beyond to solve any issues. If you have a wonky extended warranty, for example Endurance or Car Shield, they will even call and try to work with them. If not, I highly encourage you to look at their extended warranty they use. I’m not trying to sell a warranty, just saying it was much better and 50% cheaper than the ones I mentioned. Highly recommend this shop for all your car care needs! 1 Reviews William couch CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/14/2025 Comment : Outstanding customer service and work in my vehicles 1 Reviews Lamore CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/02/2025 Comment : The staff was polite enough but I figured I would keep some business locally so I brought my car to them for an estimate. There was a clunking sound and they diagnosed it for $65. They wanted $710 to replace 2 sway bar bushings. I figured it must be a very hard fix since $550 of that was labor on top of the $65. I called Cheney tire and they quoted me about $300 for the same job.I ordered the parts myself from a Subaru dealer for slightly under $20 and I m not exaggerating when I say, between removal and reinstall it was a 25 minute job .. literally 4 bolts total. I don t understand the justification for $710. Because of this, I can t justify ever taking a vehicle to them again in the future.The staff was polite enough but I figured I would keep some business locally so I brought my car to them for an estimate. There was a clunking sound and they diagnosed it for $65. They wanted $710 to replace 2 sway bar bushings. I figured More 1 Reviews Brian duffy CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 04/02/2025 Comment : Fast easy and affordable. 1 Reviews Joshua dougherty CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 03/22/2025 Comment : 1 Reviews Enid moore CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 03/14/2025 Comment : 1 Reviews Bill conner CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 03/14/2025 Comment : Very displeased and going elsewhere for car service. 1 Reviews Muriel godec CLAYTON, NY Reviewed : 03/13/2025 Comment : Amazing towing driver ! Page 1 of 35 |<< 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 → >|